How about a hilariously embarrassing story that isn’t especially funny nor even all that embarrassing?
A couple of weeks ago I did another round of my experimental-ish solo-ish comedy show Pinball at Hanging Rock (next show: 7 June at the Grand Poobah!). The sketches went well but there was a long stretch of undisciplined stand-up at the start, based around what I still think are some great ideas, all of which were lost in unnecessary background detail and improvisational dead ends. Pretty straightforward outcome, lesson learned, even when I’ve got an essentially unlimited amount of my own time to work with, I still need to tighten it up.
I also decided to bring back a segment which had been the highlight of an otherwise pretty dismal Pinball back in March, entitled “A Conversation Between Two Women About Something Other Than A Man”, in which I gracelessly earned my show a passing grade on the notorious Bechdel test by selecting two female audience members and facilitating a conversation between them about anything at all, so long as no men were involved. As tediously obsessed as I am with comedic theory, I would still be hard-pressed to explain the point of this, other than that the Bechdel test makes an important and complex point about gender disparity in popular fiction and I thought it’d be funny to address that point and then miss it completely. (In case it needs to be said: it’s not about passing, it’s about escaping the culture of screenwriting that doesn’t trust an audience to pay attention when men aren’t on screen or even being discussed.)
In March it was short and silly, and didn’t ask too much of the unsuspecting women in question, and it worked out well on a night when not much else did. The second time around, however, I wanted to make it bigger and better, but I had even less of a plan, and I filled in the blanks rather embarrassingly. March’s show, as I recall, produced about a minute of stilted but friendly conversation about chips, but this time I started asking things like, “What’s your motivation? What drives you?”, and even though that kind of dumb arrogance on my part was meant to be the butt of the joke, that’s still way too much to throw at somebody and expect anything back.
As it went on, I got further and further out of my depth, and had the awful realisation partway through that I didn’t even know what sort of character I was meant to be (dude with a genuine respect for women’s rights, yet still bothering them with a microphone and asking vague personal questions against their better wishes??). It was a mess. Not a total disaster — as far as I’m aware, I didn’t upset anybody, and I think people enjoyed it about as much as they would have enjoyed anything unpredictable and unplanned — but still unfortunately messy all the same.
So I took two relatively new arrivals to my thick ol’ head — an interest in feminism and a desire to incorporate more audience interaction into my comedy, or at least get a lot better at it should the need/opportunity arise — and I unwisely combined them with very little forethought. It leaves me with a mild variant of the shame I felt at age 11 when a kid at my school was hassling me and I lashed out at him with white-belt taekwon-do. Then, as now, the result was thankfully so inept as to be unidentifiable. But I knew!
I wish we were allowed to see more beginners. First drafts. Nervous activists. A 50-year-old Nick Cave, on stage, learning guitar.
